Back to blog

Combining a Defined Benefit Plan With a Dental Practice 401(k)

Coordinate dental practice retirement plans by separating employee deferrals, employer funding, staff costs, and adviser responsibilities.

Woman reviewing retirement plan documents at a desk

A dental practice can maintain a defined benefit plan alongside a 401(k), but the two arrangements need coordinated design, testing, funding instructions, and tax review. The owner should receive one reconciled decision file showing employee salary deferrals, employer contributions to each plan, staff obligations, administration costs, and who approves each payment.

The IRS defined benefit plan overview confirms that an employer with a defined benefit plan can have other retirement plans and identifies the enrolled actuary's funding role. This guide addresses coordination with an existing 401(k), after the dental practice preparation review has established the workforce and records.

Start with the existing 401(k) commitment

Collect the signed plan document, adoption agreement, amendments, recent testing and contribution reports, employee notices, payroll instructions, and provider contracts. Ask the current administrator which contribution promises and administrative duties already exist. A new illustration should explain how it fits those terms.

Identify whether the 401(k) has a safe harbor design, discretionary profit sharing, matching contributions, or other features requiring review. Do not assume that adding a defined benefit plan preserves every exemption or allows every employer contribution shown in an earlier standalone illustration.

The IRS qualified-plan requirements guide covers coverage, nondiscrimination, top-heavy requirements, compensation, and operating under plan terms. Request a written assessment of which rules apply separately or require coordination across the proposed arrangement. An owner-facing savings total cannot demonstrate those results.

Require advisers to accept specific deliverables

Give the actuary, 401(k) administrator, CPA, and payroll contact the same dated census and entity information. Include associate dentists, hygienists, assistants, administrative employees, departures, transfers, ownership relationships, and relevant other businesses. Have each provider acknowledge the same version.

Responsible personDeliverable to requestAcceptance question
ActuaryDefined benefit plan illustration and funding explanationWhich amounts are required, targeted, or preliminary, and for which period?
401(k) administratorContribution and testing analysis reflecting both arrangementsWhat changes from the existing design, including staff treatment?
CPACompensation reconciliation and coordinated deduction reviewWhich entity and tax year claim each employer amount?
Payroll contactDeferral mapping and payment reconciliationWhich withheld amounts have already been remitted?
Practice ownerApproved cash schedule and named payment authorizersCan the practice meet the schedule while protecting operating cash?

Ask who integrates the answers. If the actuary assumes the 401(k) administrator will handle a test, obtain the administrator's acknowledgement. Treat an unassigned calculation, filing, or notice as an open issue before approval.

Separate four money streams

First, identify employee salary deferrals, including the dentist owner's deferrals from compensation. Second, list employer matching, nonelective, and profit-sharing contributions to the 401(k). Third, show defined benefit plan funding under the actuary's instructions. Fourth, list administration and other separately paid costs.

IRS Publication 560 distinguishes elective deferrals, employer contributions, and deductions. Use those distinctions in the practice's schedule. Salary deferrals withheld from gross wages are not an additional employer contribution or extra wage expense. They still require an accurate remittance reconciliation.

Ask the CPA and administrator to review the contribution and deduction rules for the complete arrangement. A deduction conclusion requires the actual design and employer facts. Keep the tax answer separate from the cash schedule; do not subtract a guessed tax saving from the bank funding requirement.

Hypothetical: find a double count in the cash schedule

Assume a dental practice's preliminary worksheet lists $120,000 of defined benefit plan funding, $30,000 of employer 401(k) contributions, and $7,000 of separately paid administration costs. It also lists $40,000 of participant salary deferrals. All amounts are invented budgeting inputs, not allowable contributions, an actuarial illustration, market fees, or promised deductions.

The employer-funded and separately paid cost subtotal is $157,000: $120,000 plus $30,000 plus $7,000. If all participant deferrals are already included within gross payroll, adding another $40,000 to wage expense would double count them. Nevertheless, any withheld deferrals awaiting deposit belong in the actual remittance schedule.

Suppose $36,000 of the $40,000 has already been remitted and $4,000 remains in payroll liabilities. The remaining deferral remittance is $4,000. If none of the employer funding or fees has been paid, the remaining payments illustrated here total $161,000: $157,000 plus $4,000. This is a cash reconciliation, not permission to postpone deposits. Use the dates supplied for each obligation.

Show employee costs across both arrangements

Request owner and non-owner employer funding separately for each plan, with employee deferrals in their own column. Require the provider to explain employee benefits and the assumptions behind testing. Do not treat a hygienist's decision against salary deferrals as proof that the practice owes no employer benefit for that employee.

Ask the advisers to document PBGC coverage or an applicable exception. Professional-service and ownership exceptions require factual review. Include premiums if applicable and identify filing responsibilities. A dental practice label alone does not settle coverage.

Approve coordination and ongoing monitoring together

For plans subject to ERISA, the Department of Labor's provider guidance recommends comparing service information, documenting selection, and monitoring performance and fees. Confirm who handles amendments, notices, testing, actuarial work, filings, and corrections.

Our multi-dentist proposal comparison helps compare competing offers. This coordination file instead establishes that the selected providers' work fits together. Bring the documents and reconciled payment schedule to TaxBowl's tax team to organize the accounting and tax inputs before approving the combined commitment.

Before implementation approval, test each provider payroll mapping and distinguish legitimate definition differences from stale records.